Non-RTE Species: desk report
One row of the risk matrix, EC-02 Non-RTE Species, in the Ecological Resources section: what the record holds on it.
A desk review of the record as it stood: not a field survey and not a modelled study.
- Information cut-off
- 2023-08-01
- Row in the matrix
- EC-02 Non-RTE Species
Downloads
This report as a Word file, and the engine's own files for the whole run.
- This reporttamsin-ridge-solar-and-storage-EC-02.docx · Word · 48 KB
- The engine's risk matrixRiskMatrix_TamsinRidgeSolarandStorage.xlsx · Excel · 108 KB
- The engine's permit matrixTamsin Ridge Solar and Storage Permit Matrix.docx · Word · 61 KB
1Finding
Impacts likely but may be easily resolved
up toResource is present, likely difficult to address
The engine shows this rating as 2-3
- The rule
Code computed the rating from the assessor's inputs:
impact_likely=yes -> 2
Set by the rule
- Decision
- Released
- Evidence state
- VERIFIED · field study or agency determination
The assessor's comments
ODNR identifies hayfields and reclaimed mine grasslands in the eastern site as MBTA grassland bird nesting habitat. Bobolink and eastern meadowlark were observed in Parcels 12 to 14. An active bald eagle nest lies about 0.9 mile east of the boundary. Clear and mow outside April 15 to July 31.
Worst case
If what is pending at the cut-off went badly, the same rule gives a higher rating.
- Scenario
Mapping places the hayfield and grassland nesting habitat within the buildable area, so grassland bird habitat is lost despite timing restrictions.
- Step still pending
- Habitat mapping of hayfield and grassland against the final layout, and nesting bird surveys
- Inputs in the worst case
- Extent core · Avoidable partly · Pathway standard · Impact likely yes
- The rule on the worst case
- worst case: extent=core, avoidable=partly -> 3
- Claims that make it plausible
- C-a6b564438f, C-86e65362cd, C-a6c169a2d9
2What the record shows
The five inputs
Present: yes
ODNR states hayfields and reclaimed mine grasslands in the eastern part of the site provide MBTA grassland bird nesting habitat (C-a6b564438f). The field survey saw bobolink and eastern meadowlark in the hayfields of Parcels 12 to 14, and red-tailed hawks nesting (C-86e65362cd). An active bald eagle nest is recorded about 0.9 mile east of the boundary (C-4108f1157c, C-fb295f9d24).
Cites C-a6b564438f, C-86e65362cd, C-4108f1157c, C-fb295f9d24
Extent: unknown
Hayfield acreage and its position relative to the buildable area are not documented. Reclaimed grassland is about 80 acres (7%) of the Project Area (C-a6c169a2d9); habitat is described only as the eastern part and Parcels 12 to 14 (C-a6b564438f, C-86e65362cd). The eagle nest is outside the site (C-4108f1157c).
Cites C-a6c169a2d9, C-a6b564438f, C-86e65362cd, C-4108f1157c
Avoidable: partly
Timing avoids nest take: clear and mow outside April 15 to July 31 (C-a6b564438f, C-76760b5938). The eagle nest is about 0.9 mile away, beyond the 660-foot buffer that applies January 15 to July 31 (C-7366342eed, C-cb44061226). Judgment for a typical build: some grassland nesting habitat will be converted to arrays, so some habitat loss remains. The draft layout clears about 38 acres of trees (C-c0e63f6881).
Cites C-a6b564438f, C-76760b5938, C-7366342eed, C-cb44061226, C-c0e63f6881
Pathway: standard
MBTA compliance by avoidance, seasonal clearing and mowing windows, and eagle buffer checks (C-76760b5938, C-cb44061226, C-4e22698f2d). The nest is about 0.9 mile away, so no eagle take permit is indicated (C-4108f1157c). F-MBTA and OH-ODNR-SOLAR apply; F-BGEPA is conditional on nest proximity.
Cites C-76760b5938, C-cb44061226, C-4e22698f2d, C-4108f1157c
Impact likely: yes
Judgment for a typical solar build: grading and fencing on hayfields and reclaimed grassland with documented nesting grassland birds is likely to disturb protected bird habitat (C-a6b564438f, C-86e65362cd). Tree clearing of about 38 acres adds disturbance of woodland bird habitat (C-c0e63f6881).
Cites C-a6b564438f, C-86e65362cd, C-c0e63f6881
Supporting statements (10)
Each claim the row cites: the statement in the assessor's words, then the quote the engine found on the page.
C-4108f1157c
The Division has a record of an active bald eagle nest about 0.9 mile east of the project boundary.
Quoted from page 2 The Division has a record of an active bald eagle nest about 0.9 mile east of the project boundary.
ODNR Environmental Review - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage Project (ODNR 23-0477) · DR-0011 · Page 2 · 2023-05-02
Source agency_determination · Claim type presence · Polarity presence · Confidence high · Quote check exact, 100 of 100
C-4e22698f2d
Service recommends scheduling vegetation clearing outside the primary nesting season where possible.
Quoted from page 1 schedule vegetation clearing outside the primary nesting season where possible.
Official Species List - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage · DR-0010 · Page 1 · 2023-04-12
Source agency_determination · Claim type recommendation · Polarity neutral · Confidence medium · Quote check exact, 100 of 100
C-7366342eed
ODNR records an active bald eagle nest about 0.9 mile east of the East Block, beyond the 660-foot disturbance buffer.
Quoted from page 1 ODNR records an active bald eagle nest about 0.9 mile east of the East Block, beyond the 660-foot disturbance buffer.
Bat Habitat Assessment and Vegetation Survey - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage Project · DR-0007 · Page 1 · 2023-06-20
Source consultant_memo · Claim type presence · Polarity presence · Confidence high · Quote check exact, 100 of 100
C-76760b5938
Mow and clear outside April 15 to July 31 to protect nesting migratory birds, and recheck eagle nest location before construction.
Quoted from page 1 mow and clear outside April 15 to July 31 to protect nesting migratory birds; recheck the eagle nest location before construction.
Bat Habitat Assessment and Vegetation Survey - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage Project · DR-0007 · Page 1 · 2023-06-20
Source consultant_memo · Claim type recommendation · Polarity neutral · Confidence high · Quote check exact, 100 of 100
C-86e65362cd
Bobolink and eastern meadowlark were seen in hayfields of Parcels 12 to 14, and red-tailed hawks nest in the West Block woodlots.
Quoted from page 1 Bobolink and eastern meadowlark were seen in the hayfields of Parcels 12 to 14, and red-tailed hawks nest in
Bat Habitat Assessment and Vegetation Survey - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage Project · DR-0007 · Page 1 · 2023-06-20
Source field_study · Claim type presence · Polarity presence · Confidence high · Quote check exact, 100 of 100
C-a6b564438f
Hayfields and reclaimed mine grasslands in the eastern site provide nesting habitat for MBTA-protected grassland birds; mow and clear outside nesting season.
Quoted from page 2 Hayfields and reclaimed mine grasslands in the eastern part of the site provide nesting habitat for grassland birds protected under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act.
ODNR Environmental Review - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage Project (ODNR 23-0477) · DR-0011 · Page 2 · 2023-05-02
Source agency_determination · Claim type presence · Polarity presence · Confidence high · Quote check exact, 100 of 100
C-a6c169a2d9
About 80 acres (7%) of the Project Area is reclaimed surface-mined grassland.
Quoted from page 2 Reclaimed surface-mined grassland 80 7%
Bat Habitat Assessment and Vegetation Survey - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage Project · DR-0007 · Page 2 · 2023-06-20
Source field_study · Claim type extent · Polarity presence · Confidence medium · Quote check exact, 100 of 100
C-c0e63f6881
Forest covers about 41 acres and the draft layout clears about 38 acres of trees.
Quoted from page 1 The draft layout clears about 38 acres of trees.
Bat Habitat Assessment and Vegetation Survey - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage Project · DR-0007 · Page 1 · 2023-06-20
Source field_study · Claim type extent · Polarity presence · Confidence medium · Quote check exact, 100 of 100
C-cb44061226
Keep tree clearing and construction more than 660 feet from the eagle nest during January 15 through July 31.
Quoted from page 2 Keep tree clearing and construction more than 660 feet from the nest during the nesting season, January 15 through July 31.
ODNR Environmental Review - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage Project (ODNR 23-0477) · DR-0011 · Page 2 · 2023-05-02
Source agency_determination · Claim type recommendation · Polarity neutral · Confidence high · Quote check exact, 100 of 100
C-fb295f9d24
Bald eagles nest in the area; avoid clearing or disturbance near active nests.
Quoted from page 1 Bald eagles nest in the area. Avoid clearing or disturbance near active nests
Official Species List - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage · DR-0010 · Page 1 · 2023-04-12
Source agency_determination · Claim type presence · Polarity presence · Confidence high · Quote check exact, 100 of 100
3Permits and requirements
The requirements tied to the rows of this report, by level. Each quote from dated law is shown with its source, the version in force on the cut-off and the basis for it.
Federal (2)
Compliance through avoidance (no incidental take permit program)
F-MBTA · U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
- Applicability
- Conditional
- Instrument
- Migratory Bird Treaty Act (16 U.S.C. 703-712); 50 CFR Parts 10 and 21
- Trigger
- Vegetation clearing or construction where migratory birds nest.
- Description
Prohibits take of migratory birds, nests and eggs. Managed by clearing vegetation outside the nesting season and avoiding active nests.
- Typical timeline
No permit applies, so there is no agency processing time; compliance is by avoidance. The Service's Nationwide Standard Conservation Measures call for scheduling vegetation removal outside the peak bird breeding season and, where that is not possible, nest surveys generally no more than five days before the activity.
- Version of the law on the cut-off
- with the Service's Nationwide Standard Conservation Measures
- As of the cut-off
As of the cut-off: An FWS rule (86 FR 1134) took effect defining the Act's prohibitions as applying only to actions directed at migratory birds, so incidental take was not prohibited. (2021-03-08) FWS revoked the January 2021 rule (86 FR 54642); the Service again treats incidental take as prohibited by the Act. (2021-12-03)
- Verification
- PACK_PENDING_QUALIFIED_REVIEW
- Source
- pack:federal
- In the permit matrix
- F-MBTA
Legal basis: 3 quotes from dated law
Quoted from the law, page 5 The MBTA (16 U.S.C. 703-712), prohibits the taking of any migratory bird or any part, nest, or egg, except as permitted by regulation.
Source National Bald Eagle Management Guidelines 2007 · page 5 · version undated
Cited for requirement
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 2 Stressor: Vegetation Removal Conservation Goal: Avoid direct take of adults, chicks, or eggs. Conservation Measure 1: Schedule all vegetation removal, trimming, and grading of vegetated areas outside of the peak bird breeding season to the maximum extent practicable.
Source Nationwide Standard Conservation Measures birds · page 2 · version 2022-12
Cited for trigger and avoidance timing
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 2 Conservation Measure 2: When project activities cannot occur outside the bird nesting season, conduct surveys prior to scheduled activity to determine if active nests are present within the area of impact and buffer any nesting locations found during surveys. 1) Generally, the surveys should be conducted no more than five days prior to scheduled activity.
Source Nationwide Standard Conservation Measures birds · page 2 · version 2022-12
Cited for timeline: pre-clearing nest survey
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Eagle nest buffers; eagle incidental take permit if disturbance cannot be avoided
F-BGEPA · U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
- Applicability
- Conditional
- Instrument
- Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (16 U.S.C. 668-668d); 50 CFR Part 22 (incidental take permits at 50 CFR 22.80 since the January 2022 redesignation)
- Trigger
- Eagle nests or concentration areas near construction.
- Description
Protects bald and golden eagles, their nests and eggs from take, including disturbance.
- Typical timeline
No regulatory processing time: the Service declined to put permit issuance timeframes in the eagle regulations because the time varies enormously with the scale and complexity of the activity, any NEPA analysis and the quality of the applicant's data (81 FR 91494, response to comments). Typical: 12 to 24 months for an eagle incidental take permit; nest buffers and seasonal avoidance can remove the need (basis: practice, not stated in the sources).
- Version of the law on the cut-off
- 50 CFR Part 22 as redesignated in January 2022
- As of the cut-off
As of the cut-off: Revised eagle permit regulations took effect (81 FR 91494), including incidental take permits of up to 30 years. (2017-01-17) 50 CFR Part 22 was redesignated (87 FR 884); the permit for eagle take associated with, but not the purpose of, an activity is now 50 CFR 22.80. (2022-01-07)
- Verification
- PACK_PENDING_QUALIFIED_REVIEW
- Source
- pack:federal
- In the permit matrix
- F-BGEPA
Legal basis: 3 quotes from dated law
Quoted from the law, page 1 This permit authorizes take of bald eagles and golden eagles where the take is compatible with the preservation of the bald eagle and the golden eagle; is necessary to protect an interest in a particular locality; is associated with, but not the purpose of, the activity; and cannot practicably be avoided.
Source 50CFR22 · page 1 · version 2023-08-01
Cited for requirement: permit for eagle take associated with, but not the purpose of, an activity
In force from 2022-02-07 to 2024-02-11
eCFR versioner: 50 CFR part 22, same text on 2022-05-20, 2022-09-12, 2023-04-22, 2023-08-01 and on every amendment date between them; amendment dates 2016-12-16, 2017-01-17, 2020-03-26, 2020-04-02, 2022-01-07, 2022-02-07, 2024-02-12, 2024-04-12, 2024-10-17, 2024-12-31
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 1 Disturb means to agitate or bother a bald or golden eagle to a degree that causes, or is likely to cause, based on the best scientific information available, (1) injury to an eagle, (2) a decrease in its productivity, by substantially interfering with normal breeding, feeding, or sheltering behavior, or (3) nest abandonment
Source 50CFR22 · page 1 · version 2023-08-01
Cited for trigger: disturbance of eagles
In force from 2022-02-07 to 2024-02-11
eCFR versioner: 50 CFR part 22, same text on 2022-05-20, 2022-09-12, 2023-04-22, 2023-08-01 and on every amendment date between them; amendment dates 2016-12-16, 2017-01-17, 2020-03-26, 2020-04-02, 2022-01-07, 2022-02-07, 2024-02-12, 2024-04-12, 2024-10-17, 2024-12-31
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 42 We are not including permit issuance timeframes in the regulations because the time it takes to issue a permit varies enormously depending on the scale and complexity of the activity that will result in take, the need to prepare an analysis under NEPA, the quality and completeness of the data and other information provided by the applicant
Source 81FR91494 · page 42 · version 2016-12-16
Cited for timeline: no regulatory processing time
May be cited on the cut-off date.
State (2)
Protection of state-listed wildlife and plants: no take of endangered wildlife without a Division of Wildlife permit; ODNR Environmental Review and any species surveys, including bat surveys and tree-clearing windows
OH-ESA · Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR): Division of Wildlife (state-listed wildlife and its part of the Environmental Review) and Division of Natural Areas and Preserves (state-listed plants)
- Applicability
- Conditional
- Instrument
- ORC 1531.25; OAC 1501:31-23-01 (effective 2022-07-01); ORC 1518.02; OAC 1501:18-1-03 (effective 2022-11-01); ODNR Environmental Review; ODNR Division of Wildlife and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) joint guidance for bat surveys and tree clearing (May 2022)
- Trigger
- Work that could take a state-listed endangered animal or destroy a listed plant, including tree clearing from April through September or near potential bat hibernacula, on a project that will be submitted to the OPSB.
- Description
Ohio protects endangered wildlife by rule (OAC 1501:31-23-01, under ORC 1531.25); the list includes the Indiana, northern long-eared, little brown and tricolored bats. Taking or possessing a listed animal without a written permit is generally unlawful. The statute directs the rules to provide permits for zoological, educational, scientific and propagation purposes, and the sources describe no incidental-take permit for a solar project. Endangered and threatened plants are covered by ORC 1518.02, which bars willful destruction or removal without the written permission of the owner, lessee or person entitled to possession, so its direct reach is limited where that permission exists. ODNR asks that a project going to the Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB) use its Environmental Review. ORC 4906.13(B) bars public agencies from requiring approvals or permits for a facility authorized by an OPSB certificate; whether that displaces a Division of Wildlife take permit is not addressed in the sources.
- Typical timeline
Tree clearing, as the joint ODNR Division of Wildlife and USFWS guidance (May 2022) states it: for a project outside a known bat record buffer that proposes tree clearing between April 1 and September 31 (sic, the guidance's wording), a presence/probable absence survey may be conducted between June 1 and August 15, and if none is performed presence of listed bats is assumed. Where a desktop assessment finds potential hibernacula, the guidance says to assume bats are using them and refrain from clearing trees from March 15 to November 15, or to conduct a field habitat assessment. The library holds the May 2022 edition of the guidance, the latest archived before 2023-08-01; a later edition may have replaced it before that date but could not be verified. No statutory period for ODNR's Environmental Review appears in the sources.
- Version of the law on the cut-off
- OAC 1501:31-23-01 as effective 2022-07-01 (the library text)
- As of the cut-off
As of the cut-off: USFWS reclassification of the northern long-eared bat from threatened to endangered took effect (final rule 87 FR 73488, effective date delayed to 2023-03-31 by 88 FR 4908). The May 2022 joint guidance and ODNR's July 2022 listed-species publication still describe it as federally threatened, and the guidance refers to the 4(d) rule. (2023-03-31)
- Verification
- PACK_PENDING_QUALIFIED_REVIEW
- Source
- pack:oh.json
- In the permit matrix
- OH-ESA
Legal basis: 8 quotes from dated law
Quoted from the law, page 9 The rules shall provide for the taking of species threatened with statewide extinction, for zoological, educational, and scientific purposes, and for propagation in captivity to preserve the species, under written permits from the chief.
Source ORC 1531.08 1531.25 1518 endangered species · page 9 · version 2023-08-01
In force from 1988-07-20 to 2026-10-03, section 1531.25
1531.25: version effective 1988-07-20, still the current version when the page map was checked (2026-10-03)
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 1 the following native species and subspecies of wild animals shall be designated as endangered in accordance with section 1531.25 of the Revised Code: (1) Mammals Indiana bat, Myotis sodalis Allegheny woodrat, Neotoma magister Black bear, Ursus americanus Little brown bat, Myotis lucifugus Tricolored bat, Perimyotis subflavus Northern long-eared bat, Myotis septentrionalis
Source OAC 1501 31 23 01 endangered wild animals · page 1 · version 2023-08-01
In force from 2022-07-01 to 2023-12-31, section 1501:31-23-01
1501:31-23-01: version effective 2022-07-01; first change after it 2024-01-01 (ODNR Division of Wildlife amendment (endangered wild animals list). Register of Ohio final-filed item named 1501$31-23-01_PH_FF_A_RU_20231011_0813 (filed 2023-10-11 per file name; content not retrievable)), from codes.ohio.gov version history in archive captures (one_source)
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 14 unlawful for any person to take, transport, sell, offer for sale or possess any of the native endangered species of wild animals, applying to endangered wild animals that are either resident within or migrate into or through Ohio, or hides or parts thereof listed in this rule or any other wildlife order without first obtaining a written permit
Source OAC 1501 31 23 01 endangered wild animals · page 14 · version 2023-08-01
In force from 2022-07-01 to 2023-12-31, section 1501:31-23-01
1501:31-23-01: version effective 2022-07-01; first change after it 2024-01-01 (ODNR Division of Wildlife amendment (endangered wild animals list). Register of Ohio final-filed item named 1501$31-23-01_PH_FF_A_RU_20231011_0813 (filed 2023-10-11 per file name; content not retrievable)), from codes.ohio.gov version history in archive captures (one_source)
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 2 No person shall willfully root up, injure, destroy, remove, or carry away on or from public highways, public property, or waters of the state, or on or from the property of another, without the written permission of the owner, lessee, or other person entitled to possession, any endangered or threatened plant
Source ORC 1531.08 1531.25 1518 endangered species · page 2 · version 2023-08-01
In force from 1978-08-23 to 2026-10-03, section 1518.02
1518.02: version effective 1978-08-23, still the current version when the page map was checked (2026-10-03)
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 20 (B) No public agency or political subdivision of this state may require any approval, consent, permit, certificate, or other condition for the construction or operation of a major utility facility or economically significant wind farm authorized by a certificate issued pursuant to Chapter 4906. of the Revised Code.
Source ORC 4906 Power Siting Board · page 20 · version 2023-08-01
In force from 2019-10-22 to 2026-10-03, section 4906.13
4906.13: version effective 2019-10-22, still the current version when the page map was checked (2026-10-03)
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 1 If your project meets any of the following criteria, or you are interested in a more comprehensive review, please submit for an Environmental Review. Project requires coordination with ODNR to fulfill NEPA, ESA, FWCA, or CWA requirements. Project will be submitted to Ohio Power Siting Board.
Source ODNR DOW environmental review and natural heritage requests page · page 1 · version 2023-02-03
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 6 Any Ohio project that is not within a known bat record buffer, and tree clearing between April 1 and September 31 is being proposed, may have a presence/probable absence survey conducted between June 1 and August 15 following the range-wide guidance. If a presence/probable absence survey is not performed, presence of listed bats is assumed.
Source ODNR DOW USFWS joint bat survey and tree clearing guidance 2022 · page 6 · version 2022-05
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 4 If potential hibernacula are found during the desktop assessment: - Assume bats are using these hibernacula and refrain from clearing trees from March 15-November 15 -Or- - Conduct a field habitat assessment to determine if a potential hibernaculum(a) is present within the action area.
Source ODNR DOW USFWS joint bat survey and tree clearing guidance 2022 · page 4 · version 2022-05
May be cited on the cut-off date.
ODNR conditions for solar facilities, applied through OPSB review: environmental resource surveys, wildlife-permeable fencing, pollinator vegetation, mowing season and listed-species reporting
OH-ODNR-SOLAR · Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR), whose conditions are applied through the Ohio Power Siting Board (OPSB) certificate review
- Applicability
- Likely
- Instrument
- ODNR Guidance for Proposed Solar Energy Facilities in Ohio (updated 2022-04-07), agency guidance; Ohio Solar Site Pollinator Habitat Planning and Assessment Form (version March 2018)
- Trigger
- Any proposed solar energy facility subject to Ohio Power Siting Board regulation, for which ODNR expects these conditions in the site development plan.
- Description
ODNR's solar guidance sets conditions it expects in the site development plan of every solar facility under OPSB regulation; it is guidance applied through OPSB review, and the sources show no separate permit. Surveys: resource surveys as in ODNR's Environmental Review, delineation of wetlands and streams before the OPSB application is filed, and recommended minimum buffers of 120 feet (Category 1 and 2 wetlands) and 300 feet (Category 3). Fencing: gaps of at least 6 by 6 inches for small mammals. Vegetation: at least 70% of the developed project area in beneficial vegetation, scoring at least 80 points on the pollinator form (which rewards staggered mowing), with routine mowing limited to fall and spring; the guidance says the requirement does not apply to sites committed to alternative agricultural uses to control vegetation. Listed species found in construction: 24-hour notice to OPSB staff, ODNR's Division of Wildlife and USFWS; work halted.
- Typical timeline
Before the OPSB application is filed: environmental resource surveys and delineation of wetlands and streams. During construction: notice to OPSB staff, ODNR Division of Wildlife and USFWS within 24 hours of any state or federal listed species encountered, with work that could adversely impact it halted until a course of action is agreed. During operation: routine mowing limited to fall and spring seasons, as needed.
- Version of the law on the cut-off
- As in force from 2023-06-13 (the library text)
- As of the cut-off
As of the cut-off: OPSB adopted revised rules in OAC Chapters 4906-1 to 4906-7 that add solar-facility requirements, including small-wildlife-permeable perimeter fencing and noxious-weed control. They were subject to rehearing and JCARR review and were not in effect on 2023-08-01. (2023-07-20)
- Verification
- PACK_PENDING_QUALIFIED_REVIEW
- Source
- pack:oh.json
- In the permit matrix
- OH-ODNR-SOLAR
Legal basis: 8 quotes from dated law
Quoted from the law, page 1 Disclaimer: The guidance document is non-exhaustive. Project recommendations are made on a site-specific basis and may include additional considerations. It is ODNR’s expectation that the conditions below are incorporated into the site development plan for all proposed solar energy facilities in Ohio which are subject to Ohio Power Siting Board regulation.
Source ODNR guidance for proposed solar energy facilities · page 1 · version 2022-04-07
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 1 Conduct environmental resource surveys as described in the ODNR Environmental Review process. Delineate wetlands and streams, prior to OPSB application submission.
Source ODNR guidance for proposed solar energy facilities · page 1 · version 2022-04-07
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 1 Avoid existing wetlands and adjacent woodlands. A minimum 120-foot buffer should be maintained on Category 1 and 2 wetlands. A minimum 300-foot buffer should be maintained on Category 3 wetlands to preserve ecological integrity.
Source ODNR guidance for proposed solar energy facilities · page 1 · version 2022-04-07
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 2 Fencing around panels should incorporate gaps or spaces of at least 6 inches x 6 inches to allow passage of small mammals.
Source ODNR guidance for proposed solar energy facilities · page 2 · version 2022-04-07
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 2 Solar development sites are required to plant a minimum of 70% of the developed project area in beneficial vegetation, utilizing plant species as described in Attachment A (or other suitable species as approved) and follow the Ohio Solar Site Pollinator Habitat Planning and Assessment Form with a minimum score of 80 points.
Source ODNR guidance for proposed solar energy facilities · page 2 · version 2022-04-07
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 2 Routine mowing will be limited to fall/spring seasons, as needed, to allow for natural reseeding of plantings and reduce impacts to ground-nesting birds. These requirements are intended to provide wildlife habitat, encourage water infiltration, and reduce erosion. This requirement not applicable to sites committed to alternative agricultural uses to control vegetation, as described in the vegetation management plan.
Source ODNR guidance for proposed solar energy facilities · page 2 · version 2022-04-07
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 2 The Applicant shall contact OPSB staff, ODNR DOW, and USFWS within 24 hours if state or federal listed species are encountered during construction activities. Construction activities that could adversely impact the identified plants or animals shall be immediately halted until an appropriate course of action has been agreed upon by the Applicant, OPSB staff, and the appropriate agencies.
Source ODNR guidance for proposed solar energy facilities · page 2 · version 2022-04-07
May be cited on the cut-off date.
Quoted from the law, page 1 Planned management practices for areas designated as part of the pollinator habitat site. Check all that apply. Detailed establishment and management plan developed for site 10 points Mowing Follows OPHI mowing schedule for monarchs each year 5 points Mowing is staggered over a 2 week period 5 points
Source ODNR Ohio solar site pollinator habitat planning and assessment form · page 1 · version 2023-06-13
May be cited on the cut-off date.
4What is missing
The information requests the run raised for the rows of this report, by priority: what is missing, what follows from it, and whether it holds up the decision.
Medium priority (2)
IR-c5e9053166 · Medium priority
Provide the eagle nest review or avian survey for the project area, or confirm none exists.
- Missing evidence
- Eagle nest review or avian survey
- Consequence
- Non-RTE Species is rated on partial evidence without it.
- Blocks the decision
- No
- Raised by
- completeness
IR-8469920792 · Medium priority
Provide the wildlife agency correspondence for the project area, or confirm none exists.
- Missing evidence
- Wildlife agency correspondence
- Consequence
- Non-RTE Species is rated on partial evidence without it.
- Blocks the decision
- No
- Raised by
- completeness
5Next steps and agencies
Next steps
- Schedule clearing and mowing outside April 15 to July 31; recheck eagle nest before construction, keeping the 660-foot buffer (January 15 to July 31).
- Conduct nesting bird survey and map hayfield and grassland acreage against the layout.
- Coordinate with ODNR and USFWS through the OPSB process, including ODNR mowing and pollinator conditions.
Agencies
- USFWS
- ODNR Division of Wildlife
- OPSB
6Basis and limits
This report is a desk review of the documents quoted above, as the engine read them for an information cut-off of 2023-08-01.
It is not a field survey and not a modelled study: this review made no site visit and ran no acoustic, hydraulic or other model. Where the record is silent, the report says what is missing; it does not fill the gap.
Every statement, figure and quote is the engine's record as written. The headings and connecting words are fixed text of this room, the same in every report.
Documents quoted (3)
- ODNR Environmental Review - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage Project (ODNR 23-0477) · DR-0011 · 2023-05-02 · page 2
- Official Species List - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage · DR-0010 · 2023-04-12 · page 1
- Bat Habitat Assessment and Vegetation Survey - Tamsin Ridge Solar and Storage Project · DR-0007 · 2023-06-20 · pages 1, 2
Versions and data hashes
As the engine and the exporter recorded them. Hashes are SHA-256.
- Information cut-off
- 2023-08-01
- Engine version
- 2.11.0
- Prompt version
- 2026-11-08.1
- Rows pack
- rows.json sha256 a018ecd7e4703bc1
- Federal pack
- federal.json sha256 8841c555ff35d20b
- State pack
- oh.json sha256 d4780705e1f18d09
- Local pack
- oh_carroll_county.json sha256 905cd3308848e7e8
- Data room manifest
- 0c7e80d0ad17d1e3ed4060b9702e5b1905060ae2896e9aad796a57b590005832
- Audit chain
- valid (19 events)
- QA status
- PASS_WITH_WARNINGS
- Rendered at
- 2026-11-10T15:42:40+00:00
- Run record (annex)
- 66fca2c4c0bfa90df1e8efb79c0d2f426536b41f50a6a9b6869dd85e4554fd50
- Legal source index
- 6974703924a38a8e90717222e31e444b8e540aca9b6cec809ad4ddc5b0691ca9
- Exporter
- Prism/room/exporter 1.4.0
Prism desk report · engine 2.11.0 · prompts 2026-11-08.1 · information cut-off 2023-08-01